DKIM
      Back to home
      1. Help Center
      2. FAQs
      3. DKIM

      Are there any limitations to DKIM?

      Limitations of DKIM

      DKIM has several notable limitations:

      1. Lack of From: Address Protection

        • DKIM digitally signs the email but does not verify the "From:" address. This means that while the email's integrity is assured, the actual sender's identity is not verified, allowing potential spoofing of the "From:" address.

      2. No Reporting Mechanism

        • DKIM does not provide any reporting capabilities. As a result, domain owners cannot verify if their DKIM signatures are functioning correctly or if they are being misused.

      3. No Policy for Failed DKIM Checks

        • DKIM lacks a policy statement guiding the receiving server on what actions to take if an email fails DKIM authentication. This can result in inconsistent handling of failed emails across different servers.

      How DMARC Addresses DKIM Limitations

      Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance (DMARC) builds on DKIM and SPF to address these limitations effectively:

      1. From: Address Protection through DKIM Alignment

        • DMARC requires DKIM alignment, meaning the domain in the DKIM d= parameter must match the domain in the "From:" address. This ensures that the sender's identity is protected and verified.

      2. Reporting Mechanism

        • DMARC provides a reporting feature that sends detailed reports about email authentication results. These reports help domain owners monitor DKIM and SPF performance, detect issues, and identify potential abuse.

      3. Policy for Handling Failed DKIM and SPF Checks

        • DMARC includes policy statements (p=none, p=quarantine, p=reject) that instruct receiving servers on how to handle emails that fail DKIM and SPF checks. This standardizes the treatment of failed emails and enhances email security.

      Conclusion

      While DKIM offers a valuable layer of email security, it has limitations regarding sender verification, reporting, and policy enforcement. DMARC addresses these gaps by ensuring DKIM alignment with the "From:" address, providing detailed reporting, and specifying clear policies for handling authentication failures. Implementing DMARC alongside DKIM and SPF significantly strengthens email authentication and helps protect against email spoofing and phishing attacks.